Makigumo - The Anime Manga Cinema Culture
Home Reviews News Archive About Makigumo RSS Feed RSS

Post Details

Back to News Archive.

Review: A Certain Scientific Railgun

March 20, 2010
A Certain Scientific Railgun

The picture says it all, really.

Full review of A Certain Scientific Railgun

A Certain Scientific Railgun does much better than its parent work, A Certain Magical Index, by not insisting that everything that happens is the most important event in the world. It’s lighthearted, fun, endearing, but can also tackle serious issues surprisingly well.

  • Score: 80%
  • Opinion: excellent
  • + builds on the fundamentals of an action/school life show, but tells a great story
  • + focuses on its characters over the workings of the fictional setting
  • + deeper themes of the story emerge organically through the narrative
  • + the purposeful, efficient use of its plot threads rewards you for paying attention
  • + the cast is alive and vibrant
  • + excellent visual production
  • + good casting of voice actors
  • - uneven pacing after a well-scripted first half
  • - one antagonist is outrageously cartoonish
  • Conclusion: A Certain Scientific Railgun is equal parts fun and sentimental. It rises above the pitfalls of its genre by concentrating on telling a story about people you can empathize with.

Tags: A Certain Scientific Railgun, Toaru Kagaku no Railgun, review